Skip to Content

Self managed companies: Reserch of commitment matrix

19. mája 2025 pomocou
BUH.SK - Sergii Pikalov

Your observation about the Morning Star Company's specific commitments matrix, as described in the Medium article and your research, raises an important point about self-management in organizations. Let’s unpack this to address whether Morning Star is truly self-managed or if the presence of a detailed process management system undermines that claim.


### Understanding Self-Management

Self-management, in organizational terms, typically means that individuals or teams have significant autonomy to make decisions, set goals, and manage their work without traditional hierarchical oversight. Instead of top-down control, authority is distributed, and employees are trusted to coordinate and align their efforts toward organizational goals. However, self-management doesn’t imply a complete absence of structure or accountability—most self-managed organizations still use frameworks to ensure alignment and performance.


### The Specific Commitments Matrix at Morning Star

Based on your description and the article, Morning Star’s specific commitments matrix is a tool used as part of their **Colleague Letter of Understanding (CLOU)** system. It outlines:

- **Business processes** a colleague is responsible for.

- **Decision authority** (Decide, Recommend, or Act) for each process.

- **Performance measures** (Steppingstones) tied to each process.

- **Reporting intervals** for tracking those metrics.


This matrix is part of Morning Star’s broader self-management model, which emphasizes:

- **No formal managers**: Colleagues negotiate responsibilities and commitments with peers rather than receiving directives from a boss.

- **CLOUs**: These are agreements between colleagues that define roles, responsibilities, and performance expectations, fostering transparency and accountability.

- **Peer coordination**: Colleagues align their work through mutual agreements and feedback rather than centralized control.


### Does the Matrix Undermine Self-Management?

Your concern is valid: the specific commitments matrix sounds highly structured, with defined processes, metrics, and reporting intervals, which might seem at odds with the idea of a “self-managed” organization. However, this structure doesn’t necessarily contradict self-management—it can actually enable it. Here’s why:


1. **Structure Supports Autonomy**:

   - Self-management doesn’t mean chaos or a lack of processes. Effective self-managed organizations often rely on clear frameworks to ensure everyone understands their roles and how their work contributes to the whole. At Morning Star, the matrix provides clarity on who is responsible for what, preventing overlap or confusion.

   - The matrix is not imposed by a central authority but is negotiated among colleagues. This peer-driven process aligns with self-management principles, as individuals have a say in defining their responsibilities and metrics.


2. **Decision Authority is Distributed**:

   - The matrix specifies decision-making roles (Decide, Recommend, Act), which decentralizes authority. Rather than a manager dictating decisions, colleagues have defined scopes of autonomy. For example, someone with “Decide” authority can act independently within their process, which is a hallmark of self-management.

   - This clarity ensures accountability without requiring a traditional hierarchy, as peers can hold each other accountable based on agreed-upon commitments.


3. **Steppingstones and Reporting as Accountability Tools**:

   - The performance measures (Steppingstones) and reporting intervals are tools to track progress and ensure alignment with organizational goals. In a self-managed system, these metrics are often co-created or mutually agreed upon, not unilaterally imposed.

   - At Morning Star, these metrics are tied to the company’s mission (e.g., optimizing tomato processing efficiency), and colleagues use them to self-assess and coordinate with others. This differs from traditional management, where metrics are typically set by higher-ups and used to control employees.


4. **Self-Management Requires Coordination**:

   - In large organizations like Morning Star, which processes thousands of tons of tomatoes, self-management at scale requires robust systems to coordinate efforts across teams. The matrix serves as a coordination tool, ensuring that individual autonomy doesn’t lead to misalignment or inefficiency.

   - The article highlights how Morning Star’s self-management model relies on transparency and peer agreements, with the CLOU and matrix acting as “contracts” that colleagues voluntarily enter into.


### Could It Be Seen as Process Management Instead?

Your point about the matrix resembling “highly developed process management” is insightful. Morning Star’s approach does emphasize rigorous process optimization, which is critical in their industry (tomato processing, where efficiency and quality are paramount). This focus on processes could make the organization appear less “free-form” than other self-managed models (e.g., holacracy at Zappos or Buurtzorg’s nurse-led teams). However, there are key distinctions:


- **Who Designs the Processes?** In traditional process management, a central authority (e.g., a management team or process engineer) designs and enforces processes. At Morning Star, colleagues collaboratively define their processes and commitments through CLOUs, giving them ownership over how work is structured.

- **Who Holds Authority?** In a conventional organization, managers oversee process execution and compliance. At Morning Star, authority is distributed, and colleagues self-monitor and coordinate with peers, using the matrix as a reference.

- **Flexibility vs. Rigidity**: The matrix is not a static rulebook but a living agreement that colleagues can renegotiate as needed. This adaptability aligns with self-management, as it empowers individuals to adjust their roles and processes based on changing needs.


That said, the level of structure at Morning Star might feel restrictive to some. If the matrix is overly prescriptive or if renegotiations are rare in practice, it could start to resemble a bureaucratic system, even without formal managers. The success of their self-management model depends on how much genuine autonomy colleagues have in shaping their commitments and how often they can adapt them.


### My Take

Morning Star is still a self-managed organization, as it lacks traditional hierarchical management and empowers colleagues to define their roles, negotiate responsibilities, and make decisions within their scope. The specific commitments matrix is not a sign of centralized control but a tool to enable self-management at scale by providing clarity, accountability, and coordination. However, its highly structured nature reflects the demands of their industry, which requires precise process management to succeed. This makes Morning Star’s model more systematic than some other self-managed organizations, but it doesn’t negate its self-managed status—rather, it shows how self-management can be adapted to a complex, process-driven context.


### Additional Considerations

- **Cultural Fit**: The article notes Morning Star’s emphasis on a culture of personal responsibility and mutual accountability. The matrix works because colleagues buy into the self-management philosophy and actively participate in shaping their CLOUs. If this culture weakened, the matrix could become a bureaucratic constraint.

- **Comparison to Other Models**: Compared to holacracy (with its rigid role definitions) or Buurtzorg (with minimal formal processes), Morning Star’s matrix is more process-focused but still decentralized. It’s a hybrid that balances autonomy with the need for operational rigor.

- **Potential Critique**: Some might argue that the matrix’s detailed metrics and reporting intervals could feel like “management by another name” if colleagues don’t have enough flexibility to redefine them. Without access to internal data or employee feedback, it’s hard to assess how much true autonomy exists in practice.


### Russian Translation (Per Your Earlier Request)

If you want to discuss this in Russian, the concept of the specific commitments matrix could be described as:

"Матрица конкретных обязательств определяет бизнес-процессы, за которые отвечает коллега, полномочия по принятию решений для каждого процесса (принимать решения, рекомендовать или действовать), показатели эффективности (называемые Steppingstones) для каждого процесса и интервалы отчетности по каждому показателю."

- **Матрица конкретных обязательств** (Matrica konkretnykh obyazatel’stv) for "specific commitments matrix."

- **Полномочия по принятию решений** (Polnomochiya po prinyatiyu resheniy) for "decision authority."

- **Показатели эффективности** (Pokazateli effektivnosti) for "performance measures."

- **Интервалы отчетности** (Intervaly otchetnosti) for "reporting intervals."


### Next Steps for Your Research

If you’re exploring self-managing organizations further, consider these questions to deepen your analysis of Morning Star and similar models:

1. **How flexible is the matrix in practice?** Does Morning Star allow frequent renegotiation of CLOUs, or are commitments rigid?

2. **Employee perspective**: Do colleagues feel empowered by the matrix, or does it feel like a subtle form of control? (You might search for employee reviews or case studies.)

3. **Comparison**: How does Morning Star’s model compare to other self-managed organizations like Buurtzorg, W.L. Gore, or Valve? Are their processes less structured?

4. **Outcomes**: Does Morning Star’s matrix lead to better performance (e.g., efficiency, innovation) compared to traditionally managed competitors?


If you’d like, I can search for additional sources on X or the web to find more insights about Morning Star’s self-management practices or compare it to other organizations. I could also generate a chart to visualize differences between self-managed models (e.g., level of structure vs. autonomy) if that would help. Let me know what direction you’d like to take!

BUH.SK - Sergii Pikalov 19. mája 2025
Share this post
Archivovať